Pine Tar vs Coal Tar Soap for Psoriasis and Eczema: The Complete Guide to Nature's Stinkiest Solution

Discover how 2,000-year-old tar soaps can calm angry skin when modern medicine fails—plus the science behind why tree sap and coal derivatives actually work

---

Quick Summary: This comprehensive guide explores tar soap effectiveness for psoriasis and eczema, comparing pine tar vs coal tar options. Learn the science, safety, and real-world results from someone who's been there.

---

Picture this: You're standing in the health store's soap aisle, scratching that stubborn patch of skin that just won't quit, when you spot something that looks excavated from a Victorian apothecary—tar soap. Yes, TAR. The same stuff they put on roads.

But here's the wild part: your great-grandmother was onto something, and modern science is finally catching up to what ancient healers knew all along.

If you've been following my journey, you know I've already fallen hard for Grandpa's Pine Tar Soap (spoiler: it still smells like a tire fire, but my psoriasis doesn't care). Today, we're diving deeper than my personal love affair with stinky soap. We're exploring the actual science, the pine tar versus coal tar showdown, and whether this ancient remedy is right for YOUR angry skin.

Buckle up. We're about to get nerdy about tree sap.

#The 2,000-Year History of Tar Soap

#When Hippocrates Was Your Dermatologist

Before fancy biologics and UV light boxes existed, we had trees. Apparently, that was enough.

Pine tar has been used in medicine for more than 2000 years, with Hippocrates himself prescribing it. The "Father of Medicine" was telling ancient Greeks to slather themselves in tree goo. And it worked well enough that people kept doing it for two millennia.

Think about that. We've abandoned bloodletting, trepanning, and mercury treatments (thank God), but tar soap? This sticky survivor made it through every medical revolution because it actually works.

#From Ship Protection to Skin Protection

Pine tar's medical benefits were discovered by accident—like penicillin, but smellier. Scandinavian sailors used pine tar to waterproof their ships and rigging. British sailors were literally nicknamed "tars" because they were constantly covered in the stuff.

These tar-covered seafarers noticed something interesting: their hands—despite harsh sea conditions—were surprisingly healthy. No infections. Fewer skin problems. Being perpetually sticky was actually... beneficial?

Fast forward to Colonial America, where pine tar became such a money-maker that entire forests were devoted to its production. They exported it back to Europe faster than you can say "inflammation reduction."

#The Science: How Tar Soap Works on Psoriasis and Eczema

Now for the important question: WHY does tree juice help psoriasis and eczema?

#Your Skin Cells Are Throwing a Party (And Tar Is the Bouncer)

In psoriasis and eczema, your skin cells behave like that neighbor who throws parties every night. Normal skin cells take about a month to mature and shed. Psoriasis skin cells? They're speed-running the process in 3-7 days, creating those characteristic plaques and scales.

Coal tar helps slow the rapid growth of skin cells and restore the skin's appearance. Think of tar as the responsible adult who tells everyone the party's over. It literally slows down hyperactive skin cells, giving them time to develop properly.

#The AHR Receptor: Your Skin's Hidden Reset Button

Here's where it gets fascinating. A 2013 study found that coal tar activated the aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AHR), resulting in induction of epidermal differentiation. Translation: tar flips a switch in your skin that tells it to stop freaking out and start acting normal.

Even more impressive? Coal tar restored filaggrin expression in keratinocytes and counteracted Th2 cytokine–mediated downregulation of skin barrier proteins. In plain English: it literally helps rebuild your skin's protective barrier that eczema and psoriasis destroy.

#The Multi-Action Approach of Tar Soap

Tar soap doesn't just do one thing—it's a Swiss Army knife for your skin:

• Anti-inflammatory: Reduces redness and swelling
• Antimicrobial: Fights bacteria that worsen flares
• Antifungal: Prevents secondary infections
• Antipruritic: Stops the maddening itch
• Keratolytic: Gently removes scales

#Effectiveness: What Research Really Shows

Let's move beyond theory. Does tar soap actually work in real life?

#Tar Soap for Psoriasis: The Evidence

A comprehensive review found that 84% of studies supported the use of coal tar products for psoriasis. That's not wishy-washy—that's a solid majority of research confirming effectiveness.

Some people's symptoms completely disappear, and they may have a long period of remission before the next flare. Imagine: a soap that doesn't just manage symptoms but can deliver months of clear skin.

Here's the surprising part: Studies found that lotions containing just 1% coal tar were more effective than those that contained 5% coal tar. More isn't always better. Sometimes your skin needs a gentle nudge, not a tar tsunami.

#Tar Soap for Eczema: Promising Results

The eczema research is particularly exciting. A recent randomized controlled trial found significant improvements in SCORAD scores, POEM scores, Staphylococcus aureus colonization, and IgE levels among patients who bathed with pine tar.

Translation: Pine tar didn't just improve skin appearance—it reduced harmful bacteria AND calmed the immune system's overreaction.

#Real-World Results

Here's what actual users experience:

The Good:

• 70-80% report significant improvement within 2-4 weeks
• Itch relief often starts within days
• Many achieve long remissions
• Works when expensive biologics fail

The Reality:

• Not everyone responds
• Results vary by condition severity
• Some can't tolerate smell or drying effects
• It's management, not cure

#Pine Tar vs Coal Tar: Complete Comparison

Time for the main event! Let's compare these two tar soap options head-to-head.

#Origins and Production

Pine Tar: Made from burning pine wood in low-oxygen environments. It's concentrated tree essence. 100% pine tar from Swedish pine processed using traditional carbonization is the gold standard.

Coal Tar: A byproduct of converting coal into coke or gas. Contains thousands of compounds scientists are still identifying.

#The Smell Factor

Let's address the elephant in the room—or should I say, the campfire in the bathroom.

Pine Tar: Smells like a campfire had a baby with a tire shop. However—crucially—it has a rugged, outdoorsy scent that doesn't linger on skin. Your bathroom smells like a lumber mill; you smell like a lumberjack.

Coal Tar: Strong and medicinal, like "hospital merged with coal mine." The smell announces "I have a serious skin condition." Tends to linger longer and stains more readily.

#Effectiveness Comparison

Coal tar soap is generally considered more effective than pine tar soap in treating psoriasis, as it has more scientific evidence to support its use.

However, pine tar users report gentler, more pleasant experiences with similar (if slightly less dramatic) results. It's like choosing between a sledgehammer and a regular hammer—both drive the nail, but one might crack your wall.

#Safety Profile Analysis

This is where pine tar pulls ahead decisively.

Pine Tar: Found to contain no detectable levels of carcinogenic PAHs or minimum detectable levels. As safe as rubbing tree juice on yourself can be.

Coal Tar: The cancer question has haunted coal tar for decades. While a 2010 study of 13,200 patients found no increased cancer risk with medicinal use, concerns linger. California requires cancer warnings on products with >0.5% coal tar.

#The Verdict

• Mild to moderate symptoms + gentle approach: Choose pine tar
• Severe, stubborn plaques + don't mind nuclear option: Try coal tar (with dermatologist guidance)

#Safety, Side Effects, and Warnings

Let's discuss what soap companies don't advertise in bold letters.

#Common Side Effects for All Tar Soaps

1. Photosensitivity: Both make you UV-sensitive for 24 hours. You're basically a temporary vampire. Sunscreen becomes mandatory.

2. Drying Effects: Tar strips oils indiscriminately. Moisturizer becomes your new religion.

3. Staining Issues: Coal tar especially stains everything. Pine tar is more forgiving but not innocent.

4. Hair Changes: Can make hair dry or brittle. Condition religiously if using on scalp.

#Critical Warnings for Special Populations

Pregnancy and Breastfeeding: Coal tar has been associated with spontaneous abortions and congenital disorders in animal studies and is recommended to avoid during the first trimester. Pine tar appears safer, but consult your doctor.

Coal tar applied topically to maternal skin can result in absorption by the infant through skin-to-skin contact. Breastfeeding mothers should either avoid tar soaps or be extremely careful about skin-to-skin contact.

Children: Too few clinical trials have studied coal tar as a treatment for childhood eczema. Pine tar seems gentler, but start slowly and monitor carefully.

#Complete User Guide: How to Use Tar Soap

After months of personal experience and extensive research, here's your practical roadmap.

#Choosing the Right Tar Soap

Start with pine tar if:

• You have mild to moderate symptoms
• You're sensitive to harsh treatments
• Smell matters to you
• You're new to tar soap

Consider coal tar if:

• Pine tar isn't sufficient
• You have severe plaques
• Industrial aromas don't bother you
• Your dermatologist recommends it

#The Optimal Application Technique

1. Prep: Use lukewarm water (hot water worsens inflammation)
2. Lather: Create good foam (yes, tar soap foams!)
3. Apply: Target problem areas first
4. Critical Step: Let sit for 2-3 minutes (set a timer—this matters)
5. Rinse: Thoroughly, then rinse again
6. Dry: Pat gently—never rub
7. Moisturize: Within 3 minutes. Non-negotiable.

#Realistic Timeline for Results

• Week 1: "What have I done?" phase
• Week 2: Itch begins calming
• Weeks 3-4: Visible improvements
• Month 2: Evangelical phase begins
• Month 3: You've named your soap

#Storage and Relationship Preservation

Learn from my storage container saga:

• Airtight containers are essential
• Keep bars completely dry between uses
• Use soap dishes with drainage
• Consider advance warning for household members

#Combination Strategies

Tar soap works best as part of a routine:

• Morning: Tar soap shower
• Evening: Gentle moisturizing
• Flare-ups: Tar soap plus prescribed topicals
• Maintenance: Alternate with gentler options

#Making the Right Choice for Your Skin

After extensive research, here's my honest assessment:

Tar soap is undeniably weird. It smells bizarre, looks medieval, and requires industrial-grade ventilation.

But it works. Not universally, not perfectly, but consistently enough to survive 2,000 years of medical advancement.

#Decision Framework

Psoriasis/Eczema Sufferer?
├── Tried everything? → Pine tar soap
├── Need maximum strength? → Coal tar (with supervision)
├── Smell-sensitive? → Pine tar or reconsider
└── Desperate? → Start with pine tar today

#Cost Analysis

• Pine tar soap: $4-8/bar × 2 bars/month = $8-16/month
• Prescription copays: $30-100+/month
• Quality of life improvement: Invaluable

#Final Thoughts: Ancient Wisdom Meets Modern Need

Two thousand years of tar soap use teaches us something profound: Sometimes old solutions address fundamental problems better than modern complexity. While laboratories create expensive molecules, trees have been producing anti-inflammatory compounds since before humans discovered fire.

Will tar soap cure your skin condition? No. These are chronic conditions we manage, not defeat.

Can a bar of stinky tree juice deliver clearer skin, better sleep, and short-sleeve confidence?

In my experience, absolutely.

Just warn your loved ones about the smell. And invest in apology chocolate.

---

Ready to try tar soap? Read my detailed 3-month review of Grandpa's Pine Tar Soap or find it on our equipment page.

Disclaimer: I'm a psoriasis sufferer who found something effective, not a medical professional. Always consult healthcare providers about skin conditions, especially if pregnant, breastfeeding, or treating children.

#Quick Reference: Pine Tar vs Coal Tar Soap

#Key Takeaways

✓ Both tar soaps have 2,000+ years of proven use
✓ Work by slowing skin cell turnover and reducing inflammation
✓ 84% of studies support effectiveness for psoriasis
✓ Pine tar is gentler, coal tar is stronger
✓ Side effects are manageable with proper use
✓ Not a cure, but an effective management tool
✓ Always moisturize after use
✓ Allow 3-4 weeks before judging results